Take the poll here.
What about Mayers? He will after all be the elder statesman on the team at 33 if Sundin and McCabe are gone. He's tough, skates hard and protects his teammates. A leader for sure but will he be on the ice enough?
Devereaux or Moore also exemplify the determination and team-first attitude that I think a captain should have.
Why do we always make the best player the captain?